Tag Archives: the War Guilt Clause

Review: Military Strategy and the Origins of the First World War (Miller, et al.)

miller-et-al

Military Strategy and the Origins of the First World War (Revised and Expanded Edition): An International Security Reader.

Straining at gnats and swallowing camels, most of the writers in this book join the throng of revisionist Great War Guilt theorists who overlook the obvious: that the First World War was exactly what Willy wanted.

Consisting of chapters by separate authors, the book includes much politically correct thinking about the Great War. Divided into two parts, it first examines “Offensive Military Doctrines and the Great War” in five essays which focus on aspects of the notion of military provocation, which, couched as “the cult of the offensive” is attributed to all of the belligerents on both sides.

Certainly, hostile “encirclement” was the favorite internal and international propaganda used by the Kaiser, to justify his invasion of Luxembourg, Belgium and France (events which were accompanied by baldfaced lies). But just because Germany’s emperor wholeheartedly believed in “might is right” and “possession is nine-tenths of the law” does not mean that the members of the Entente were driven by the same obsessions because they ended up in combat with him.

The Entente was made up of gentlemen (yes, even the French, who had grieved the loss of Alsace-Lorraine for more than forty years, yet throughout that time had done nothing belligerent about it), who chose to ignore the Kaiser’s rants, expecting him to get over himself, as any sassy but otherwise sane modern monarch should be able to do. But as most parents can tell you, there’s a limit to how long the warning “Don’t make me come down there” will silence the squabbling of a child who’s spoiling for a fight. The problem with the Entente was that they waited too long to do anything about the whiner: he had grown from a snotty kid to a burly adolescent bully who thought he could take what he wanted and get away with it.

The second part of the book, “Crime or Blunder? Inadvertence, Guilt, and Historical Responsibility,” consists of four essays that disagree in different ways and to varying extents with the military provocation theory, but the first three still largely sidestep the whole truth: Because the Entente’s efforts at diplomacy were ineffective to discipline the bully on the block, they were simply forced to resort to means and methods that the bully understood. Unfortunately, the Entente was not strong enough to settle his hash without help.

The saving grace of this book is its final chapter, “Clio Deceived: Patriotic Self-Censorship in Germany after the Great War.” This is where the rubber meets the road: Germany’s policy and procedures to deny its War Guilt, which even a generation after the fact took the form of persecution of those who tried to tell the truth (including Fritz Fischer, whose massive scholarly exposé of Germany’s war aims merits only a mere nod in the first part of the book). In this chapter we learn of the measures which Germany’s spin doctors took to alter the historical record that ever since have had a remarkably consistent effect on both public perceptions and political policies, worldwide.

Not for the Wilhelmine Reich, the Weimar Republic, the Third Reich, nor postwar Germany would be the kind of statement that later became the hallmark of terrorist behavior: the smugly issued announcement that they “take responsibility” (a positive-sounding euphemism for something I have always felt should be more accurately expressed by the press as “take the blame”) for what are nothing less than irresponsible acts of war. From the very first – even before the Sarajevo shot was fired – it was always part of Germany’s plan to protect its interests by lying about its intentions and denying its responsibility for prosecuting a genuine war of conquest that was inevitable only because it was what Willy wanted.

Recommended reading because the final chapter tells the truth about the origins of the First World War.

(My copy is a quality trade paperback issued by Princeton University Press, with a preface to introduce the studies, but no index.)

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

The Best Short Documentary About the First World War!

Watch it below!

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Review: The Burden of Guilt (Butler)

butler

The Burden Of Guilt: How Germany Shattered The Last Days Of Peace, Summer 1914

The author tells the story of those fragile few days by focusing separately on the actions of each of the eventual belligerents, ensuring that the reader learns the history well and becomes thoroughly conversant with the author’s thought-provoking, pointedly politically-incorrect premise.

Many modern examinations of this topic are governed by the belief that responsibility for the war should be shared. Such revisionism does not hold up when Wilhelm’s manipulative behavior is seen for what it was: a successful campaign to deceive other heads of state and public opinion into giving him the war he wanted.

I own histories of this event that have elicited horror, memoirs that have inspired empathy, and analytical studies that have evoked amazement, but this book is the first to have moved me from disbelief to disgust to dismay that ended in tears when I closed the cover.

I enjoyed the author’s literary/lyric writing style, especially his use of alliteration (I suppose that’s because I write that way), although some awkwardly redundant passages suggest a need for improved content editing, and a few startling typographical errors indicate a need for more attentive proofreading (both of which I suppose I noticed because I had to work so hard on such things in preparing my own manuscript for publication).

The book is sturdily bound in hardcover with an elegantly composed, glossy dust jacket, and a selection of photos not usually found in other books about the Great War era. Its content and appearance make this a good addition to any Great War collection.

Leave a comment

Filed under Book Reviews, Uncategorized