Tag Archives: history of warfare

Review: Christmas Truce (Brown & Seaton)

Christmas Truce: The Western Front December 1914

This is the book which Weintraub cites as the “seminal” work on the topic, and with good reason: on closer inspection of Weintraub’s book, it appears to have largely followed Brown & Seaton’s treatment of the subject, because most of the new material in Weintraub is his “What if?” final chapter. Apparently Weintraub had strong feelings about the Great War, but only enough to produce the essay that constitutes that last chapter, so in order to get his essay published, he seems to have pumped it up with excerpts from Brown & Seaton’s detailed work, a lily which he gilded with a few additional rather inconsequential findings of his own, drawn largely from later popular entertainment sources.

Be that as it may, Brown & Seaton’s Christmas Truce is definitely the best book about the controversial events of December, 1914, to have on your shelf. Fascinating detail, well-documented, and nicely presented in hardcover with a dust jacket, it would also make a good gift for a Great War armchair general. Highly recommended.


Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Review: Battlescapes (Buellesbach & Cowper)


Battlescapes: A Photographic Testament to 2,000 years of Conflict.

It’s certainly not a fault of this book that it prepares a potential visitor to the battlefields of Europe to see a whole lot of nothing. Except in the locations of memorials and cemeteries, the woods have grown back and the fields have reverted to farming. Life goes on.

That’s the way it ought to be, of course. Despite the sadness we feel when confronted with a massive loss of human life, and the disgust we feel when we consider the value of the human capital wasted and the genetic potential lost forever, it is a far greater honor to the dead for later generations to have encouraged the natural landscape to recover and thrive, and to have reaped abundant harvests from the croplands, both so thoroughly fertilized by the flesh, blood and bones of so many.

For that is essentially why they died, during the First and Second World Wars: to save beauty from the boot heels of imperial tyranny and totalitarian oppression, and to preserve lives and livelihoods assured by agriculture practiced in freedom.

This is a cloth-covered, hardbound book with a dust cover, and hefty enough from its thick, glossy pages to make it hard to handle if not read from a desktop. Concise text summaries accompany stunning color photography dominated by spacious two-page spreads that do a fine job of carrying the reader to each site. Different seasons and weather conditions are portrayed. A brief battlefield visitor’s guide offers helpful tourist information for each location, as well as some website URLs. It has an adequate index.

The First World War sites the volume visits are Ypres, the Dolomites, the Isonzo, Verdun, the Somme, and Vimy Ridge, but the book covers 28 other battlefields, dating from September, 52 BC to April, 1945, so it makes a suitable gift for any armchair general.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized