Review: German Posters in Belgium (Davignon)

German Posters in Belgium: Their Value as Evidence.

There are two copies of this book listed at The Internet Archive, but I happen to be fortunate enough to own an original, which I handle only when wearing white gloves. It’s bound in a paper cover, my copy of which is more darkly discolored than the one pictured above, and it has considerable damage to the spine, which has loosened some pages, but otherwise, the interior is in excellent condition, for a century-old publication.

The book features reproductions of posters and other documents relating to the invasion, occupation, and German atrocities committed in Belgium in August, 1914. Some exhibits are reproduced as photographs, which suffer from the limitations of the technology of the day, but still remain valuable research resources. Each poster is accompanied by a translation, as well as transcriptions of related documents and period commentary.

The Foreword by the compiler communicates the depth of feeling experienced by the people who were close to the action, and whose sense of outrage lay behind much of the rationale for the Versailles Treaty. These documents constituted proof positive of German villainy and propaganda during the invasion and violation of Belgium. A detailed table of contents guides the reader to each exhibit.

The collection makes a fine original-research companion to the exhaustive analysis that went into the writing of German Atrocities, 1914: A History of Denial.



Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Review: 100 Years of WWI (video)

100 Years of WWI.

A documentary set produced by the History Channel, this 2-disc video attacks the subject topically rather than chronologically. The theme is the technology that drove the war and arose from it.

The presentation suffers quite a bit from repetitious images and scenes (as all First World War documentaries do, to some degree), but it supplies some unique period footage along with the iconic scenes, most of which have been restored to excellent viewing condition. One of its strengths is that the almost obligatory re-enactments, featuring live action as well as computer-generated graphics, are filmed in either monochrome shades of grey or in sepia tones, and are seamlessly integrated with the historical footage. It also features reasonably well-executed, color-coded map sequences, and professional narration between interviews with various historians and voice-over readings of quotes from the war’s participants.

As a well-done, detailed examination of the technological execution of the Great War, I recommend this video for researchers and general audiences.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Review: WWI: The War to End All Wars (video)

WWI: The War to End All Wars.

This 3-disc video collection is a cheap knockoff (2011) of the  5-disc box set Trenches: Battleground WWI (2006). The people who decided to reproduce the public domain period cinematography from that presentation gave the episodes different names and rearranged them, substituted a terrible American narrator who couldn’t correctly pronounce many of the place names, substituted a horrible ragtime instrumental number for the John McCormack ditty, collected all of the video stills into one “bonus slide show” segment, and omitted the other extra features of the original set (which are not in the public domain).

Not worth the price, even used and hugely discounted. Look for the original, instead.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized